There is a long-standing argument over whether the Taj Mahal, a masterpiece of Mughal architecture in India and a topmost revenue-generating monument, was a Lord Shiva temple. Until now, several petitions have been filed with the Judiciary of India, seeking to restore the mausoleum into the previous Hindu shrine named Tejo Mahalay. Owing to the lack of evidence in the annals of mainstream Indian history, the argument has not spread out of the frying pan into the fire. However, churches are making way for temples in the United States.
A 30-year-old church in the US state of Virginia is all set to be converted into a Swaminarayan Hindu temple. Located in Portsmouth, VA, the church has been bought for $1.6 million by Swaminarayan Gadi Sansthan in Ahmadabad, India. The church is an 18,000-sq-ft edifice on a sprawling plot of five acres in Portsmouth. There is a spacious parking lot for 150 four wheelers. The idols will be consecrated at the upcoming Swaminarayan Temple in Portsmouth, Virginia once the church is refurbished as a Hindu temple-like structure from both outside and inside.
The Portsmouth church in Virginia is not the first such establishment to be converted into a temple in the United States. Churches in Los Angeles, Louisville, Pennsylvania and Ohio have been turned into Swaminarayan temples in the USA. The United Kingdom is not an exception to the conversion of churches into temples. Two churches – one in London and one in Bolton near Manchester – have made way for temples in the UK.
In 2017, a neglected church in Edison, New Jersey was acquired to make way for an Udupi Krishna temple. Though the main building of the church was not demolished, an architectural refurbishment was made to lend it the look and feel of a Hindu temple before an idol of Lord Krishna was ceremonially consecrated there. Today, the Udupi Krishna temple stands tall on the sprawling plot of 4.5 acres, which includes a parking lot for 600 cars, in Edison, New Jersey. As many as 1000 devotees could be accommodated, at a time, for prayers inside the temple. The Udupi matt authorities cited the shortage of vacant plots as the main reason for the purchase of an abandoned church to make way for a new temple.
Churches in the United States are making way not only for temples but also restaurants and pubs. Several media reports reveal that the total number of churches in the US has been reduced to less than a half till date. Currently, 80% of the 250,000 Protestant churches in the US are either non-functional or abandoned. Nearly 4000 people stopped going to the church every other day, according to various sources. Even Catholic churches in the United States are almost on the verge of being declined in numbers. The younger generation’s religious indifference, declining attendance and high maintenance costs are some of the reasons why churches in the United States are facing closure.
A similar fate is awaiting many Hindu temples in North America, according to Jay Srinivasan, the admin of ‘IACUS’ group for Indian Americans on Facebook and a resident of Boston. He doubts that the day is not far when Indian American communities will be required to adopt temples in the US, just as Indian government approached corporates and celebs to adopt centuries-old monuments for regular maintenance.
He opines, “Most of the Indian American kids do not believe in temple rituals. Only a small percentage (perhaps, less than 10%) of the second-generation Indian American kids go to a temple regularly, which is not more than once a month. The remaining 90% don’t.” He said uninhibitedly, “All my 3 adult daughters have donated ZERO dollars to temples since they turned 18. Most probably, they went to the temple once in the past 12 years.”
“Most of the Hindu temples in North America are mired in debts. They are competing for donation with each other. A major source of revenue for Hindu temples in USA is new immigrants from India, including H1B workers. Added to the mounting issue are priests building their own private temples all over the country. In Boston alone, there are more than two private temples, the funds of which go to the priests who own them. Atop that, many software professionals are eating into revenues for temples by having turned to the priestly profession. They work in the IT corridor at daytime, and perform wedding rituals on weekends,” said Jay Srinivasan in no uncertain terms.
The crux of his arguments is that Indians in North America should stop building new temples in order to let the existing ones survive.